SOAP vs REST API: Which One Is the Best for Your Project?

This article provides a concise comparison of REST (Representational State Transfer) and SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol), exploring their differences, use cases, and suitability for various applications. Choosing the right protocol is crucial as it impacts a project’s scalability, performance, security, and integration. REST is a lightweight, stateless architecture ideal for scalable web applications, while SOAP is a protocol designed for secure, reliable, and complex transactions. 

Understanding the strengths and limitations of each helps CTOs and CPOs select the best web service protocol for their project needs, whether it requires REST’s simplicity or SOAP’s robust standardization.

Let’s do it together with ProCoders!

What is REST?

REST, or Representational State Transfer, is an architectural style for designing networked applications. It relies on standard HTTP methods and is designed to be simple, stateless, and easily scalable.

REST uses standard HTTP methods like GET, POST, PUT, DELETE, and PATCH to perform operations on web resources. It’s an architectural style, not a protocol, meaning it provides guidelines and best practices rather than strict standards.

Key Principles

• Statelessness: Each client request must contain all the information needed to understand and process the request. The server does not store any client state between requests.
• Client-Server Architecture: REST separates concerns between the client and server, allowing them to evolve independently.
• Cacheability: Responses from the server can be cached to improve performance and scalability.
• Layered System: REST supports a layered architecture where intermediaries can be used to improve scalability and security without the client knowing.
• Uniform Interface: REST relies on a uniform and predefined set of operations, enhancing the simplicity and interoperability of different systems.

How REST Works

• HTTP Methods: REST utilizes standard HTTP methods.
  • GET retrieves data from a server.
  • POST submits data to a server to create a new resource.
  • PUT updates an existing resource.
  • DELETE removes a resource.
  • PATCH partially updates a resource.
• Data Formats: REST typically uses lightweight data formats such as JSON or XML for communication. JSON is the most commonly used due to its simplicity and ease of use with JavaScript.
• Stateless Communication: In REST, each request from the client must include all the information needed for the server to process the request, ensuring the server does not retain any client state, which simplifies the server’s architecture and improves scalability.

Pros and Cons of REST

Advantages of REST

• Flexibility and Scalability: REST can handle multiple data formats (JSON, XML, HTML, etc.) and scales easily with cloud-based and distributed applications.
• Performance: Being lightweight, REST is faster and more efficient, particularly for web services where low latency and high throughput are crucial.
• Widespread Adoption: REST is widely used in modern web services and APIs, making it a familiar choice for developers and ensuring extensive community support.

Disadvantages of REST

• Lack of Standardization: Unlike SOAP, REST does not enforce a strict standard, which can lead to variations and inconsistencies in how RESTful services are implemented.
• Security: REST lacks built-in security features, so developers must implement additional security measures, such as HTTPS, OAuth, or token-based authentication, to protect RESTful services.

What is SOAP?

SOAP, or Simple Object Access Protocol, is a protocol used for exchanging structured information in the implementation of web services. Unlike REST, which is an architectural style, SOAP is a protocol with strict standards and rules for communication between applications.

SOAP is designed to enable applications to communicate over a network, regardless of platform or language. It uses a standardized XML format to structure data, ensuring robust communication and interoperability between different systems. SOAP is typically chosen for applications where strict security and reliability are paramount.

Key Principles

• Rigid Standards and Rules: SOAP follows a strict set of standards defined by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), which ensures consistent messaging and operations across different platforms.
• Enveloping Data: SOAP messages are enveloped in a specific XML structure, which includes a header and a body. The envelope element is the root of a SOAP message and defines the start and end of the message.
• Strong Typing through XML: SOAP relies on XML for message formatting, which supports strong typing. This ensures that the data is precisely described and validated against a schema, reducing errors and improving data integrity.

How SOAP Works

• Message Format: SOAP messages are strictly formatted in XML. The use of XML allows for complex data structures and types to be defined and transmitted between services, making SOAP highly versatile in handling various data formats.
• Communication Protocols: SOAP is not limited to HTTP; it can operate over several protocols, including HTTP, SMTP, and TCP. This flexibility allows SOAP to be used in diverse network environments and communication scenarios.
• Built-in Error Handling: SOAP provides a built-in error-handling mechanism that allows detailed reporting of faults and issues that may arise during communication, ensuring robust and reliable message exchanges.

SOAP Pros and Cons

Advantages of SOAP

• Security: SOAP supports the WS-Security standard, which provides comprehensive security features, including encryption, authentication, and integrity checks, making it suitable for applications that require secure transactions.
• Reliability: SOAP supports ACID (Atomicity, Consistency, Isolation, Durability) transactions and reliable messaging protocols like WS-ReliableMessaging, which ensures message delivery even in the presence of network failures.
• Interoperability: Due to its strict adherence to standards, SOAP ensures high interoperability across different platforms and languages, making it a reliable choice for enterprise-level applications that need to integrate disparate systems.

Disadvantages of SOAP

• Complexity: SOAP is more complex to implement and use compared to REST. It requires a deeper understanding of its standards and rules, along with the intricacies of XML-based messaging.
• Performance: SOAP is a heavier protocol due to its reliance on XML and additional overhead associated with its standards (e.g., WS-Security, WS-ReliableMessaging). This can result in slower performance compared to lighter alternatives like REST, especially in low-bandwidth or high-latency environments.

Key Difference Between RESP vs SOAP API

A Table: Difference Between SOAP and REST API

Key Differences	REST	SOAP
Protocol Structure	REST is an architectural style, not a strict protocol, that uses standard HTTP methods (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE, PATCH). It offers flexibility in design and implementation.	SOAP is a protocol with a rigid set of rules and standards defined by the W3C. It specifies a precise messaging format and set of operations, making it more formal and structured.
Communication Style	REST is stateless, meaning each request from the client to the server must contain all the information needed to fulfill the request. It is designed primarily for point-to-point communication using standard HTTP.	SOAP can be either stateless or stateful. It supports a variety of communication protocols beyond HTTP, including SMTP and TCP, making it versatile for different network environments.
Data Formats	REST primarily uses JSON due to its lightweight nature and ease of use, but it can also support XML, HTML, and plain text formats.	SOAP strictly uses XML for message formatting. This enables complex data structures and strong typing, but adds additional overhead.
Performance and Speed	REST is generally faster because it uses smaller message sizes and has less overhead. This makes it ideal for web and mobile applications where performance is crucial.	SOAP tends to be slower due to the larger XML message sizes and the additional processing required for its various standards, such as security and reliability protocols.
Security	REST relies on underlying security measures, such as HTTPS, for secure communication. It lacks built-in security features and requires additional layers to be implemented for enhanced security.	SOAP has built-in security features like WS-Security, which provide comprehensive support for secure and reliable messaging, including encryption and authentication.
Error Handling	REST uses a simpler approach to error handling, typically relying on standard HTTP status codes (e.g., 404 for Not Found, 500 for Server Error) to indicate success or failure.	SOAP provides robust error handling through its SOAP fault element, allowing detailed error information to be conveyed within the SOAP message itself.
Use Cases	REST is ideal for web services that require high scalability, flexibility, and performance. It is commonly used in mobile and web applications where lightweight and fast communication is needed.	SOAP is preferred for enterprise-level applications that require high security, reliability, and ACID compliance, such as in financial services, telecommunications, and healthcare.

SOAP API vs REST API: Use Cases and Scenarios

When to Use REST

• Web and Mobile Applications: REST is ideal for web and mobile applications where speed and flexibility are essential. Its lightweight nature and use of standard HTTP methods make it perfect for environments where rapid development and responsiveness are critical.
• Public APIs: REST is widely adopted for public APIs because of its simplicity, ease of use, and the ability to support multiple data formats like JSON and XML. This makes it accessible for developers and easy to integrate with various platforms.
• Cloud Services: REST is well-suited for cloud services where scalability is a priority. Its statelessness allows for easy scaling of services, making it a preferred choice for cloud-based applications that require high availability and performance.

When to Use SOAP

• Enterprise Applications: SOAP is the go-to choice for enterprise applications where security, reliability, and transaction integrity are crucial. Its strict standards and built-in security protocols like WS-Security make it suitable for applications requiring stringent compliance and data integrity.
• Payment Gateways: Due to its support for secure and reliable messaging, SOAP is commonly used in payment gateway integrations where secure transactions and data confidentiality are critical.
• Telecom and Banking: Industries such as telecommunications and banking prefer SOAP for its robust security standards and reliability features, which ensure safe and consistent data transmission across various networks.

ProCoders Experience: eCommerce App Development with API Integration

During our collaboration with a retail and logistics company (under NDA), ProCoders developed a comprehensive eCommerce solution that included both web and mobile applications. As part of the project, we created a custom API to support core functionalities such as secure payment processing, live order tracking, and real-time inventory management. This API ensured seamless communication between different components of the system and third-party services, enhancing the overall efficiency and user experience.

Results

Our tailored API solution played a crucial role in the successful deployment of six high-performing applications, addressing the client’s business needs for scalability and security. The applications were delivered on time, fully featured, and well-received by users, demonstrating the effectiveness of our API development in creating a reliable and integrated digital platform.

REST API vs SOAP API: Integration and Compatibility

REST Integration

• Ease of Integration: REST is easy to integrate with modern web technologies and platforms, supporting a wide range of data formats and using standard HTTP methods. Its simplicity allows developers to quickly build and deploy APIs without needing complex setups.
• Interoperability: RESTful services work well across different programming languages and environments, enhancing their compatibility with diverse systems. This makes REST a versatile choice for modern application development.

SOAP Integration

• Compatibility with Legacy Systems: SOAP is well-suited for integrating with legacy systems and applications that require a high level of standardization. Its strict adherence to standards ensures consistent messaging and operations, making it a reliable choice for older systems.
• Middleware and Tools: SOAP often requires specific middleware and tools for seamless integration. While this can add complexity, it also provides robust support for various enterprise-level features like security, transactions, and messaging reliability.

REST and SOAP API: Future Trends

REST Trends

• Growing Popularity: REST continues to gain traction, particularly in microservices, serverless architectures, and cloud-native applications. Its simplicity, scalability, and stateless nature make it a preferred choice for modern software development, where agility and flexibility are paramount.
• Evolutions: While REST remains popular, there is an increasing interest in alternatives like GraphQL, which provides more flexibility in querying data. Other advancements include evolving RESTful APIs to better integrate with newer technologies and protocols, ensuring that REST continues to adapt to the changing landscape of web development.

SOAP Trends

• Niche Usage: SOAP remains relevant in specific industries that require robust security, complex transactions, and strict compliance with standards, such as financial services, telecommunications, and healthcare. Its structured nature and extensive features make it ideal for these environments.
• Adaptation: Some newer implementations are beginning to integrate RESTful principles into SOAP services, creating hybrid models that leverage the strengths of both approaches. This trend reflects an effort to modernize SOAP while maintaining its core benefits, such as reliability and security.

API REST vs SOAP, Which Is Better: Conclusion

When choosing between REST and SOAP, consider the specific needs of your project. REST is ideal for applications prioritizing speed, scalability, and simplicity, while SOAP is better suited for projects where security, reliability, and transaction integrity are critical. Evaluate your requirements carefully to select the most appropriate web service protocol for your application.